CO129-157 - Sir MacDonnell Acting Governor Sir Kennedy - 1872 [4-5] — Page 435

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

2

not

by

or comma

the existing

able to give "pellabile" to

law "competent

evidence,

and

the section merely provides that

so far

as persons are concerned,

such persons

the Ordinance does not affect their previous position. I therefore

see no variance between that section

and the Ordinance for

the treatment of prisoners.

The re-enactment deals with

the state

of law which exists independent of the

earlier Ordinance.

There is no doubt much

force in Mr. Dall's remarks as to

the advisability of introducing

measures here, the principles of which have not received recognition

in the mother country.

433

But that rule is certainly subject to the limitation imposed by

the special circumstances which must occasionally call for exceptional remedies.

As to the present case, I am somewhat encouraged by

the admission of finding in the English papers - just brought by the French Mail, that a Bill for the amendment of the Law of Evidence containing clauses for the examination and cross-examination of prisoners, has been laid before Parliament.

Edit History

2026-05-20 17:13:00 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
2 not by or comma the existing able to give "pellabile" to law "competent evidence, and the section merely provides that so far as persons are concerned, such persons the Ordinance does not affect their previous position. I therefore see no variance between that section and the Ordinance for the treatment of prisoners. The re-enactment deals with the state of law which exists independent of the earlier Ordinance. There is no doubt much force in Mr. Dall's remarks as to the advisability of introducing measures here, the principles of which have not received recognition in the mother country. 433 But that rule is certainly subject to the limitation imposed by the special circumstances which must occasionally call for exceptional remedies. As to the present case, I am somewhat encouraged by the admission of finding in the English papers - just brought by the French Mail, that a Bill for the amendment of the Law of Evidence containing clauses for the examination and cross-examination of prisoners, has been laid before Parliament.
Baseline (Original)
2 not by or comma the existing ble to give "pellabile " to law "competint evidence, and the section merely provides that } } so far as ersons are concerned, such Jursons : the Ordinance does not affect their previous position. I therefore Aw no variance between that section and the Ordinance for of prisoners. e camination -enactment deals with the That state of law which exists independent of the earlier Ordinance. There is no doubt much in Mr. Dall's remarks as to justice in Mr. Ball's the now. advisability of introducing measures here, the principles of which have not revived recognition > in the mother leantry 433 But chat rule is certainly subject to the lincitation imposed by C X C the f the optional circumstances bolony which must vecasionally call for exceptional remedies. As to the present somewhat encoura I am som VVA SUA C couraged by adment of finding in the English papers - just brought by the French Mail, chat a Bill for the amendment the Law of Evidence con clauses for ever for Evidence containing the the er examination and crop-es camination. -prisoners, has been laid before "Parliament: That MARIANO), should it of
2026-05-20 17:13:00 · Baseline
View content

2

not

by

or comma

the existing

ble to give "pellabile " to

law "competint

evidence,

and

the section merely provides that

} }

so far

as

ersons are concerned,

such Jursons

: the Ordinance does not affect their previous position. I therefore

Aw

no variance between that section

and the Ordinance for

of prisoners.

e camination

-enactment deals with

the

That

state

of

law which exists independent of the

earlier Ordinance.

There is no

doubt much

in Mr. Dall's remarks as to

justice in Mr. Ball's

the

now.

advisability of introducing

measures here, the principles of which have not revived recognition

>

in the mother leantry

433

But chat

rule is certainly subject to the lincitation imposed by

C X C

the

f

the

optional circumstances bolony which must vecasionally call for exceptional remedies.

As to the present

somewhat encoura

I am som

VVA SUA C

couraged by

adment of

finding in the English papers - just brought by the French Mail, chat a Bill for the amendment the Law of Evidence con clauses for

ever

for

Evidence containing

the

the er

examination and

crop-es

camination.

-prisoners, has been laid before

"Parliament:

That

MARIANO),

should it

of

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.